Marc Marquez vs Valentino Rossi: MotoGP GOAT debate settled

Marquez is about to confirm his GOAT status (Credit: Apex Agency)
Connor Andrews is Formula 1 and MotoGP writer for GPblog and various outlets. Having worked in motorsport for 15 years for leading companies, he has interviewed the sports biggest names and attended multiple Grands Prix.
Ahead of Marc Marquez’s 10th world title, a key voice has explained what makes his achievements better than those of any other rival.
The Ducati rider is set to clinch his record-equaling eighth premier-class championship at the Portuguese Grand Prix, with Jorge Martin and Marco Bezzecchi needing miracles to even keep things going into the Valencia finale.
The feat will lift him over former rival Valentino Rossi in the all-time list behind only 15-time world champion Giacomo Agostini, and Angel Nieto, who didn’t win any titles in the premier class.
Debates about the ‘Greatest of All Time’ have been raging in the build-up to the event, and we took a look at why Agostini has a solid case statistically.
Read also
ADVERTISEMENT
Yet it’s hard to argue with Marquez as the overall, package, and former rival and five-time champion Jorge Lorenzo has put his compatriot top of his list.
His father and rider trainer Chicho agrees, and has even gone into more depth about why Marquez has been even better than the numbers suggest.
Marc Marquez faced tougher rivals than Valentino Rossi
He explained: "Marquez has beaten the best. And that makes his numbers even more valuable.
“If we look at the numbers, Marc has achieved extraordinary results. But when judging a champion, you also have to consider another factor: the quality of the opponents he has had to face.
ADVERTISEMENT
“There have been riders who dominated during periods when the competition was not as strong.
“Take Mick Doohan, who won five consecutive world championships. After him came the titles for Criville and Kenny Roberts Jr., then the Valentino Rossi era began.”

Chicho Lorenzo thinks Rossi struggled against the modern greats (Credit: Red Bull Content Pool)
Turning to Marquez’s great rival Rossi, he continued: “Until 2009, Valentino had impressive numbers. He was winning practically every other race.
“If he had stopped at that point, he would have left statistics that would have been incredibly hard to match.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Instead, he continued racing for another twelve years, winning far less. In the meantime, though, opponents of a completely different calibre had arrived.
"First came Dani Pedrosa, then Casey Stoner, who won two world championships, and Jorge, who won three in MotoGP.
“Finally, Marc Marquez arrived. And Marc found himself competing against some of the greatest riders in history. He managed to beat them.
“Of course, some, like Valentino, were already at a later stage of their careers. But it remains an extraordinary achievement.”

Marquez has been through injury hell again this season (Credit: @marcmarquez93)
ADVERTISEMENT
Not only does Chicho Lorenzo think the quality of competition strengthens Marquez’s ‘GOAT’ case, but also his remarkable comeback.
In 2020, his MotoGP career looked close to over when numerous arm operations and a hasty return from surgery ended his season.
The following four seasons saw his form drop off a cliff as he struggled to deal with physical problems, but a switch to Gresini Ducati from Honda in 2024 revitalised him, before jumping up to the factory team in 2025 and winning his ninth title.
Marc Marquez's injury comeback strengthens his greatest-ever claim
Reflecting on the extraordinary comeback, Chicho Lorenzo said: “You have to consider everything that happened to him afterwards: the injuries, the operations, the years of difficulty and his ability to come back and win the world championship.
ADVERTISEMENT
“It is historic. I don't know how many other athletes could have done what he did.
“We have seen striking images of the effects of those injuries on his body. Yet he kept fighting. To do something like that, you need a particular kind of character.
Read also
Don’t miss GPblog in Google
Mark us as a preferred source and our articles will appear more often at the top of Top Stories.
Add as a preferred / source on Google




