MotoGP GOAT debate: Statistics challenge Marc Marquez's ranking

Who is the MotoGP GOAT? (Credit: Red Bull Content Pool)
Connor Andrews is Formula 1 and MotoGP writer for GPblog and various outlets. Having worked in motorsport for 15 years for leading companies, he has interviewed the sports biggest names and attended multiple Grands Prix.
Jorge Lorenzo has had his say on the MotoGP GOAT debate, so why can’t we?
The five-time champion said that, in his view, Marc Marquez will surpass Giacomo Agostini as the sport’s greatest when he wins his impending 10th world title.
That will be his eighth in the premier class, equaling Agostini’s record, which has stood since 1975.
It will also see him leapfrog Valentino Rossi in titles, with the pair having identical records across Grand Prix racing’s three tiers up until this season.
However, Agostini has 15 across three different tiers of Grand Prix racing, a record that will likely never be beaten.
ADVERTISEMENT
Lorenzo ranks Marquez as MotoGP's GOAT
Yet Lorenzo puts the 84-year-old Italian third in his ranking, calling him the ‘Pele’ of GP racing, arguing there was more mechanical inequality during his era.
However, he put Marc Marquez first on technique, again using a footballing analogy to compare his compatriot to Lionel Messi.
Read also
"For me, Marquez is technically better; if we're talking about technique, Marquez is the Messi of motorcycles."- Jorge Lorenzo
ADVERTISEMENT
Rossi slotted in second due to intelligence and racing in close quarters, rounding out a top three few can argue with, even if they dispute the order.
The greatest of all time debate has only ever been between the trio, but we’ve delved into the statistics, and they somewhat dispute Lorenzo’s take…
Using statistics from MotoGP’s official database, we’re able to compare all of their results, except for pole positions, with Agostini’s records incomplete.
MotoGP statistics reveal Agostini's extraordinary dominance
Agostini has won the most races overall on 122, with Marquez recently passing Rossi (106) into second with 115.
ADVERTISEMENT
However, when you break down their wins as a percentage of race starts, Agostini’s dominance becomes overwhelming.
The former MV Agusta rider has won 58.94 per cent of the races he entered, compared to Marquez’s 35.10 per cent and Rossi’s 26.62 per cent.
He’s also achieved podiums in 76.81 per cent of his races to Marquez’s 57.28 per cent and Rossi’s 54.40 per cent.
Now you may be screaming at your computer: “What about just premier-class titles!” and you’d be right to do so.
ADVERTISEMENT
Agostini not only competed in more than one series per-season, but he also achieved seven of his titles in the 350cc category, so you may be expecting a drop off.
There is, but he’s still way ahead.
Read also
Premier-class win percentages tell a similar story
In MotoGP or 500cc, Agostini has won 52.31 per cent of races to Marquez’s 35.71 per cent and Rossi’s 23.92 per cent.
| Category | Overall leader | Premier-class leader |
| Win percentage | Agostini (58.94%) | Agostini (52.31%) |
| Podium percentage | Agostini (76.81%) | Agostini (67.69%) |
| Pole percentage (Agostini not included) | Marquez (35.10%) | Marquez (34.82%) |
| Second-place percentage | Agostini (16.91%) | Marquez (17.41%) |
| Third-place percentage | Rossi (12.27%) | Rossi (13.17%) |
ADVERTISEMENT
Lorenzo’s argument still has its value, with MV Agusta supplying 17 straight riders’ titles from 1958 to 1974. However, the person to end that run was Agostini on a Yamaha.
He also competed against, and beat, fellow legend Mike Hailwood, who had an 84 per cent win race in the premier class.
The modern era is clearly more competitive, but given Agostini’s record and his dominance, Marquez may need at least one or two more championships to surpass him, particularly in the eyes of the older generation.
Read also
Don’t miss GPblog in Google
Mark us as a preferred source and our articles will appear more often at the top of Top Stories.
Add as a preferred / source on Google





